The good news? Just because Halloween feels different now that you’re grown up, it doesn’t mean you can’t relive those moments and share them with your little ones. In fact, thanks to a collection of trusty online treat retailers, you can probably still purchase every type of candy that filled your pillowcase back in the day. Here, all the old-fashioned and classic candies that will still speak to you, whether we’re talking Root Beer Barrels, Rock Candy, Bubble Tape, or Boston Baked Beans.